Very interesting article in The Sunday Age today about e-books and school libraries:
Students to dump textbooks for e-books
August 16, 2009
HEAVY book-filled school bags could soon be a thing of the past, with the e-book industry claiming most of students’ textbooks will be contained in light hand-held portable devices within three years.
The internet-linked reading devices will store hundreds of e-textbooks bought online or borrowed from school libraries.
”E-textbooks will be mainstream within three years,” the executive director of DA Direct, Australia’s largest distributor of portable reading devices and e-books, Richard Siegersma, predicted.
Mr Siegersma said digital technology would lead to the costs of e-textbooks falling in a year to 18 months.
”There will be just-in-time and customised delivery to flexible, full-colour screens; textbooks with audio and video components; touch screens for handwriting and margin note-taking and text highlighting,” he said.
Speaking at a conference of school librarians in Melbourne last week, Mr Siegersma told them to prepare for the transition from print to e-readers, e-books and e-textbooks.
While book lovers in the US can already access thousands of digital titles via Amazon’s Kindle e-reader, users of the new technology complain they can be slow to upload, screens are black and white, page-turning is slow and titles are limited to certain publishers.
Mr Siegersma said technological breakthroughs, such as flexible, full-colour screens along with improved digital management and delivery systems, will revolutionise the way students access information.
Pressure from educational institutions, public libraries and government will also force print book publishers to address pent-up demand for more titles to be made available online.
The acting head of cultural studies at Macquarie University and author of The Book Is Dead, Long Live the Book, Sherman Young, agrees.
”The world is at the e-book tipping point and librarians will be the vanguard of the introduction of e-textbooks,” Dr Young told the conference, organised by Curriculum Corporation and the School Library Association of Victoria.
”Book culture is still confused with print culture and it is really only this year people have started to get e-books.”
In 2005, Macquarie University library bought 16,651 books in print form, rising to 16,764 in 2007.
By comparison, the number of e-books bought rose from 896 in 2005 to 68,719 in 2007.
However, many obstacles stand between e-textbooks and classroom domination, according to Australian Copyright Council lawyer Sneha Balakrishnan.
”Some schools are already in the process of negotiating licences tailored to their needs,” Ms Balakrishnan said.
”But there are still lots of issues to be worked through.”
Several Melbourne secondary schools have trialled e-books with students and staff in the past year with mixed results.
At the selective boys’ secondary Melbourne High School, students were not persuaded by the new technology.
While enjoying e-book mobility and easy access to multiple titles, they complained of slow data uploading, slow page-turning and too few titles available free.
Wesley College’s head of library and information services, Wilma Kurvink, trialled 18 e-readers with staff and students.
”Digital rights management restrictions at the point of sale have been developed for individuals on personal computers with credit cards, but publishers have not yet envisaged libraries as part of the mode or thought of building a lending system,” Ms Kurvink said.
”School libraries have used very traditional acquisition models but that will not work with this new technology and we need to start forming collaborative groups to work with publishers in partnership.”
I cannot wait for this to become a reality. Not only will it make every kid hold every textbook on one device, but it will also save the world with the savings of paper, ink, glue, transportation cost, etc. Bring it on.
I’d argue in favour of giving it a bit more time before we jump enthusiastically onto this bandwagon. Boosters and spruikers still abound. I’m not so keen to see the death of the book in its paper format in any case.
Paper offers lots of advantages, including its leisure / pleasure factor – you don’t tuck yourself up in bed with a nice computer. The disadvantages of these approaches are clearly there, as the article suggests. And going electronic doesn’t mean no greenhouse gases – the emissions of the computer sector of the economy are reckoned to be at least equal to those of the aviation industry according to what I’ve read.
As someone who spends a lot of time with electronic ‘books’, I can suggest to you that the reading experience is rather different as well. Skimming is the order of the day, rather than the more reflective style of reading that a printed book affords. I also find I get eyestrain more readily from Googlebooks than I do from the paper version. So, while there are definite advantages to e-books there are other advantages to printed books. I think the jury is still out!